Also note the three links that David Brooks includes in the New York Times essay linked above. Quoting David Brooks,

• "Heather MacDonald’s account of being pilloried at Claremont McKenna College"
• "Andrew Michta laments the loss of Western confidence in an essay in The American Interest."
• "Edward Luce offers a response in his forthcoming book 'The Retreat of Western Liberalism.'"

For Twitter discussion around this essay, see my Storify story "Defending the Principles of Western Civilization While Excoriating Bad Behavior Then and Now."